Tuesday, August 01, 2006
leapfrog the dog and brush me daddy-o
Warning: long, boring and possibly not worth it
Reading all of the reaction (on various message boards) to the demise of Top of the Pops got me thinking about the things people read into coverage of a subject. (I'm writing this whilst watching Top Cat so forgive the typos/non-sequiturs).
Quite a few men have heralded the coverage as evidence of 'the BBC's bias against rock'. I saw no evidence of this: Quo appeared more times than any other group; U2 did an outside broadcast. My argument would be that if the coverage was proof of any bias, it showed one against disco, funk, country and 60s garage, as neither of the programmes contained any of these (randomly selected) genres.
Someone else claimed that terrestrial music programmes never represent his taste in music (basically, Warp records). Who in their right mind listens to this shite anyway? This screams of, "I love my music more than you, I've gone to the trouble of hanging around the Record and Tape Exchange scratching my chin and looking at Aphex Twin rarities, whilst never bothering to find about about music that other people like".
No-one ever wins 'my music is better than your music' arguments because music is necessarily linked to experience and taste, so this is definitely not what this thread is about. I suppose I just thought it interesting that many of the women commenting on the programme loved the archive footage, whilst the majority of blokes found it 'not serious enough' or 'not enough men with guitars'.
The upshot of my moping is that I'm always reminded of 'Disco Sucks' every time I hear someone complain about 'lack of rock', which makes my hackles rise every time.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
Am I the Melanie Philips of musical taste??
I still sometimes go on her blog to marvel at the way in which someone can sound as if they live on Pluto.
Haha, I have to say there are a couple of Philips-esque nonsequiturs in there ;)
"Who in their right mind listens to this shite anyway?"
I do, and quite right there's not enough of it on telly! Since when did it ever stop me liking anything else? And what's that got to do with the price of carrots anyway?
Jamie x
ooops, sorry Jamie!
I'm sure if the Aphex Twin wanted to play on Later... ('I'll take it...LLLLATER!'), he'd be allowed.
I'd have to say, my least favourite type of music after Oi! and Death Metal is crazy electronic mentalism such as that which Richard James produces.
Plus, I'm not really complaining about the Aphex Twin, I'm complaining about the way that Popular Music has become all about being exclusive and only liking music that no-one else likes. Surely that's the opposite of popular?
Let people just like what they like!
Stop your corporatist music policy!
But the 'death of fun' in music means no more 'Jocky' Wilson Says!
I may be taking this fun thing too seriously but it's only because no-one else does!
(I'm shouting, sorry).
What happened to Doctorin the Tardis or Double Dutch? Now we've got the music we deserve: James Blunt and myriad dirgey guitar bands.
Laura is just saying the current hegemony of rock rules ok is a load of bollocks - and rightly so ...
Pop is so dire and dull these days - I mean, razorlight FFS ... ;)
Pppppaytes
Actually, I didn't mind their first album, but they were a bit cheeky in assuming that no-one had ever heard Marquee Moon.
Post a Comment